|
Archives
Latest Entries
Links
|
Jeff Haynie's ramblings about business and technology is home at http://blog.jeffhaynie.us/.
August 2008
Tuesday August 26, 2008
Posted by: Jeff Haynie at 1:26PM EST on August 26, 2008
Michael Mealling has taken over the task of organizing this year’s Barcamp Atlanta given my recent move to Mountain View, California. Registration is now open. The event will be held on October 17-18, 2008 in Atlanta, GA at the Georgia Tech ATDC. This is the same location as we had last year. If you’ve never attended a barcamp or missed last year, you should consider coming. It’s not only for pure technical folks, I would especially encourage others in different areas to attend (like marketing, sales, business development, etc). Barcamp is a very fun and mind-expanding experience and it’s a great place to network with other people. Wednesday August 13, 2008
Posted by: Jeff Haynie at 7:57PM EST on August 13, 2008
Today, I had the new tenant orientation at our new cool digs in Mountain View, California. Our office is located in downtown Mountain View on Castro Street. The location is pretty amazing. The building is 12 stories (I believe) and houses a few other familiar names like Red Hat and WSO2. In fact, WS02 is directly next door, which is awesome, since they’re a partner of ours. How cool.
The office is still being finalized but we should be able to move in this Friday. Today, they put the first coat of paint on the walls.
The office is pretty much ready to move in. The previous tenant had ugly yellowish colored walls and we needed a little Appcelerator colors on some of the walls to help liven things up a bit.
The office is on the 8th floor of 444 Castro Street. So, you’ll get some amazing views of Mountain View and the surrounding areas from the office. The office is on the corner of the building and you have sunlight from all points in the office. The most wonderful thing about the office, beside the location, is the location. It’s just 4 blocks from our new house. No more Georgia 400 commuting every morning! At this point, they should be done with the painting for our move in on Friday. Of course, the most important part of any move-in for a technology company is the Internet service. We are hoping that will be complete on Friday since the building as on-net access and is already provisioned. We are getting a 10 MBps pipe so we should have good access to the internets. Tuesday August 12, 2008
Posted by: Jeff Haynie at 7:06PM EST on August 12, 2008
My last post generated a lot of great discussion about the good, bad and ugly in the Atlanta startup ecosystem. Thanks for everyone who sent me updates directly, via twitter and right here in the comments on my post. I also appreciated the one or two not so pleasant emails I received. You don’t have to agree with my perspectives on things — and that’s OK. Sorry that I pissed some of you off. My original intent was to provide some discussion in the community in a way to create a dialog that allows us to move forward. I think I’ve done that. It’s now up to you guys, the community, to take it from here. Before I finally end my blogging about the startup ecosystem in Atlanta, I figured I’d depart with one last post on a more positive note. I want to highlight 2 great companies that I think are under-funded and currently dismissed (no fault to the founders or their businesses). I’ll speak specifically about each below, but both are great companies with great prospects. Will they be billion dollar businesses? Who the hell knows? However, they’ve got a lot of early traction, good people and deserve the community and investor support in Atlanta. As a disclaimer, I’m somehow involved in both companies - not financially by any means - but as a friend/advisor/cheerleader/customer/partner. Regardless of my involvement, I think these 2 companies serve as the great hope for companies being created in Atlanta. Loopfuse
Loopfuse was started by Roy Russo and Tom Elrod a year or so ago. They had been thinking about it when they were still at Red Hat (after the acquisition of JBoss) and I’ll never forget the night I met with them to talk about starting the company and what their plans were. My advice: “quit your day job”. Like a lot of first-time entrepreneurs with good paying jobs and families - that was not something that was as easy as it sounded. But they did it. And, they struggled through building out the business - and they’ve really built something great. Not only a great product, but a great set of satisfied customers paying them real dollars every month. And some big customers. Appcelerator is a (tiny) customer too - and we put them through the ringer and they made the product better for us and we’re happy. These guys tipify what local, first-time, startup entrepreneurs go through. They don’t have MBAs and they’ve never been CEO of anything. But they’re passionate, stubborn and just-fine-thank-you if they have to prove it to the world. And they’re doing it one day, one customer at a time. Loopfuse makes a lead marketing product and it kicks butt. Every person with an online website / business in the world should be using this software if you care about turning those web site visitors into satisfied, life-long customers. You can think of Loopfuse as a Web2.0 version of Eloqua that doesn’t suck and that you can actually afford. Tom and I worked together at Vocalocity. He and I co-authored JBoss Remoting together and worked on some of JMX for JBoss. Tom later left Vocalocity to join JBoss full-time as a lead developer. Roy joined Tom at JBoss and was the lead for JBoss portal. They’re tech guys and now they’re full-time entrepreneurs building something with real value. Here’s the thing. These guys will eventually raise money - and my bet it will be before next spring. However, my 2nd bet is that they’ll raise money from the west coast if they don’t raise regional money this Fall. I don’t have any particular insight on this — this is just my opinion. They’ve got a lot of people who they’re helping - companies that have raised a lot of money out here. And, they’re really helping them making their businesses better. If the local investor scene doesn’t jump on this, they’ll be another Appcelerator quick. This is a great opportunity to really get in and help these guys out. I know they’ve been busting their butts working day-and-night to keep up with the business. They barely have any time to talk with anyone about investment because they’re busy running their company. Watch out Atlanta, if you don’t get smart and fund these guys now - you may lose your chance soon. Skyblox
Dave Payne started Skyblox around a year or so ago. Dave’s an ex-Earthlink guy that worked in the local wifi group in business development. I met Dave through Andrew Zuercher who works for us at Appcelerator. Dave also knows a lot of the same people in Atlanta so we instantly hit it off. Skyblox is a really bold concept. Local marketing is the next big thing if you’ve been stuck under a rock. It’s where the big boys - Google, Microsoft, etc - are going. And Skyblox is dead in the middle of this with their Wi-Fi access point lead to local marketing and content. Think Web2.0 meets City Search + Yelp + Yahoo Local. We worked with Dave to help him launch Skyblox in Atlanta. I think Dave thought he’d only get a handful of places in the highlands and some other local neigborhoods in Atlanta when they launched. Boy was he wrong - they got a lot of neighborhood’s signed up and from everything I’m seeing and hearing, they can’t sign them up fast enough. And, they haven’t even started their multi-city launch yet - but I think they’re seeing a lot of demand and success just right here in Atlanta. This is another set of folks that are heads down and kicking butt. They’re making it through blood, sweat and tears. And, like Loopfuse, they’ll definitely get some attention outside of town if the local scene doesn’t wise up, quick. These guys have a big idea and it’s certainly not without concerns and likely capital intensive. But, if they can quickly replicate what they’ve done in Atlanta across the remaining major cities in the U.S., they’ll quickly lock up the entire local content/search/marketing marketplace. So, in summary, here ya go Atlanta. Let’s see what we can make of these two great companies. They’re bootstrapping it, they have revenue and customers. They’re big, bold business models that will require sufficient capital to get to the next stage. And, if the bet is right, they’ll have a nice ROI. Best of luck to you. If you’d like any helping getting in contact with them, please email at jhaynie [at] gmail [dot] com. Last thought: if I didn’t mention your company, don’t get upset. there’s lots of other companies. I’m just highlighting two i know about well. Friday August 8, 2008
Posted by: Jeff Haynie at 3:45AM EST on August 8, 2008
Before I start this long-winded post I want to give a disclaimer for everyone that attempts to spend the time to read this: this post is my thoughts based on my viewpoint and will hurt some people’s feelings. I’m trying to give an honest account from my perspective. Think of it as a constructive exit interview. If you don’t like it or disagree, that’s fine — I can appreciate that. If I step on your toes, I’m sorry - but I feel like I need to say a few things to help clear the air and hopefully give some perspective. As most people have heard as of last week, I have decide to relocate my family and the Appcelerator headquarters from Atlanta, GA to Mountain View, California - in the heart of silicon valley. There have been a whole host of reasons for this - some I will attempt to explain here. I am going to also attempt to outline some thoughts on what I think Atlanta needs to do to prevent others from doing the same. Appcelerator and Atlanta First, it’s important to know that Appcelerator will continue to remain in Atlanta and will continue to invest in Atlanta. We have around 12 employees still in Atlanta (only 4 people, including myself, from Appcelerator made the move), we will continue to have an office and hopefully we’ll grow the local Atlanta office. Jeff and Atlanta If you didn’t know, I’m an Atlanta-native. I was born in Gainesville, GA and most of my family still remains in or near there. My family and I will continue to be back in Georgia quite often as we can. I love Atlanta for so many reasons. Also, it’s important to know that this is not the first time I have left the area. Each time I left and came back, my horizons have expanded and I’ve been blessed with new opportunities. I first left Atlanta in 1989 to join the U.S. Navy and spent almost 4 years in Tokyo, Japan (with brief stops in Chicago, IL and Whidbey Island, Washington for training). I left Atlanta again around late 1996 for Jacksonville, Florida and returned in 1999 to join Jeff Levy in starting eHatchery - just as the dot com boom was happening. I’m leaving 9 years later and I plan on returning one day. I hope when I return next time, as before, my life will be improved and I will have grown professionally and personally. And, that’s the challenge in front of me and my family. I’d like to talk with you about why I decided to leave and my perspective on the startup climate in Atlanta. A little background I’ve been doing the startup and tech entrepreneurial thing in Atlanta since around 1993. My entrepreneurial experience actually goes back to 1983 when I was quite young. My first company was called Bizzare Software. My step-brother and I tried to make a go at games for the TI-99/4A when we were teenagers (the first game we tried to make was a break dancing game). We ran out of memory since we only had 16K if I remember. However, since 1993, I’ve been part of 3 fairly decent size VC-funded ventures and associated in some way with many many more. I have personally been involved in raising around ~$35M in venture capital from at least 6 different venture funds and lots of local angels. So, from one point-of-view, I have some experience doing the startup thing. In fact, to be honest, I’ve raised a lot of money and been involved in losing most of it to date. It’s not fun losing other people’s money - at least, not to me. I don’t like losing my own money and I really, really hate losing other people’s money - especially when I know they’ve invested in me personally. At eHatchery, my parents personally invested $250,000 of their own money as well. Yeah, that really hurts. At Vocalocity, we raised a lot of local money (and West Coast money as well) and we didn’t have the outcome Mike and I should have achieved. There were some very odd and unusual circumstances that eventually caused an eventual premature acquisition that I can’t talk about. However, we should have done better. I still feel very unhappy about how we ended that chapter. Failure, probably as much if not more than success, really shapes a person. I’m a very driven individual if you don’t personally know me — and I’m very passionate. However, I’d like to think I’m also self-aware and always thinking a lot about how to improve myself and my organization. I work hard, demand exceptional results and don’t like to give up. I’m a serial entrepreneur. I would do what I do even if I never made money. I don’t really do it for the money — I’ve calculated before that I would have made much more money I would have had a “regular job”. However, I hope I never have to get a real job. I will do this till I die most likely. When I started Appcelerator with Nolan Wright almost 2 years ago after Vocalocity - I had no idea ultimately what we’d come up with. However, I knew 2 things: I wanted to start another software company and I wanted to eventually get a shot at raising money and succeed at creating a great return. There were a lot of specific life-lessons I could apply this time around and things always seem to go much smoother with each venture. I think failure really helps you avoid pitfalls - and much faster. From the outset, I had a very specific plan about how I wanted to grow the company, even though we had no idea what the company would do. I had a few specific objectives:
We accomplished all 3 objectives. Appcelerator has been an amazing ride so far, even though we’re just getting started. It feels like everything we’ve set out to do, we’ve done. Not always at the speed I’d like, but certainly, with results that basically have matched expectations. People around me know that I had very specific ideas about how things would come together with our first investment. However, I really struggled with one major issue: what to do with the local investor community. That’s probably a really strange issue for some locals, I understand. I’ll try and explain. I don’t have the patent on the prevailing opinion about local VC community. The opinions and frustrations are real and they’re not something that we should just ignore. There are pretty big problems with the local startup community. Here’s what I think are some of them:
Local Investors We don’t have any real early stage venture investors in Atlanta. OK, investors, go ahead and get pissed and stop reading if you’d like. But, it’s the honest truth. Noro-Moseley is one of the largest and oldest firms in Atlanta. They have some good guys there (Greg Foster has recently joined and he seems like a great guy) like Alan Taetle. However, I’m sorry to say this, these guys aren’t early stage guys. They don’t understand early stage. Period. That’s not to say they haven’t made early stage investments - they have. For example, Clearleap. They invested along side Trinity. Trinity is a great Valley firm. We spent time with them. But here’s the rub. Noro probably wouldn’t have done the deal alone, nor would they have done the deal if it was 3 guys just out of GA tech with no experience (in fact, the founders are ex-N2Broadband guys who had a good exit). Despite what Alan said in a comment on Lance’s blog, Noro had the opportunity to do the Appcelerator deal - 100% as the only lead investor - on a silver platter. Alan and Greg know that - even though they’ll try and say they didn’t publically. But the true story is that I gave Alan one week to put a term sheet on the table which had a told me and several others many times he would. In fact, Alan told several people around town that they wouldn’t lose the Appcelerator deal even before we had decided to raise a round. I’ve known Alan for a long time and I’d like to think of him as a friend - so I know he’ll be pissed at me for putting this out there. However, it’s the truth and I’m sorry if the truth sometimes hurts. I think ultimately, Alan was probably paranoid that he’d lose the deal anyway and I was just using Noro to price the deal. A number of inside people know this: I had told everyone that I would give them the deal if they put a decent term sheet on the table we could live with (which I think was reasonable with expectations). I even told Alan I would give them dibs for a week before we talked to anyone — which I honored. In fact, we waited almost 2 weeks before deciding that they were playing games. Alan insisted on 2 things that I think ultimately was a proxy for their true colors: he wanted detailed, 5 year financials and several days to “dig through the financials” and he wanted to spend time with our 2 key prominent advisors. In fact, that’s part of normal due diligence especially for a round size we were talking about. However, it’s also symptomatic to part of the local investor problem. I’ll contrast that with all the investors I met with on the west coast: we didn’t even talk about financials to late in the discussion. Let me be straight here: we had very detailed financial models and we have great advisors which are very active. However, when you don’t know what’s important and you don’t understand how to evaluate a deal like Appcelerator, you gravitate towards what you’re comfortable with. The problem with Noro isn’t that they’re not a good firm. They are not experienced early stage investors. They haven’t had a great track record and most of their partners haven’t had any amount of reasonable success. OK, I said it. I’m sorry, but it’s the truth. It doesn’t mean that their money isn’t greener than the next guys - it is. And they have a decent amount of money in their latest fund. They should be really leading the charge in Atlanta - but they are not. I hope that changes. I think for a region to have a vibrant startup community, it needs some anchor VC tenants that can lead the charge. We’re really missing that in Atlanta. And here’s another hard-to-stomach fact. West coast money specifically told me they did not want local money involved. Even after I had decided that Noro wasn’t a good fit and moved on, I was still trying to angle how I could let them in to the deal in some capacity. Up to even after signing a term sheet, I talked 3 different times about a possible local partner and I continue to get the same line: “why? what value can they possibly provide”. You see, you raise money for more than just the money. Don’t get me wrong, all money is green. However, $4M from a west coast VC is so much different than $4M from a local VC. That’s a hard pill to swallow I realize. But, everyone knows it. Get over it. Sig said in the Atlanta Business Chronicle article that could (my paraphrasing) help find a VP of Sales but couldn’t help with contacts at Google or Microsoft. Hello…. VP of Sales is important, but to most early stage startups, Google … Microsoft … yeah, you need to have relationships there. It’s just too important for so many reasons. Side note about a smaller local VC I will say that I did have a good experience with Nelson Chu and the partners at Kinetic. While Nelson didn’t invest in Appcelerator, he was extremely aggressive and helpful. Kinetic is out of Maryland and invests all over but Nelson’s base has been in Atlanta for a long time. Nelson’s been a wall flower at events in Atlanta for a long time — Nelson now has some new money and I really hope he gets active in some smaller, local deals. He’s very smart and tries to work hard and really understand what you’re doing. A new fund? There’s rumors that Said Mohammadioun is rasing a small fund, around $80M or so I hear. OK, another good example of a persistent problem: Not enough money based on their profile as a VC. They’re going to only be able to make around 5-7 $5M deals to be able to keep enough dry powder ready for follow-on rounds. At least, I’ve been told that’s their target. Maybe they’ll do some $1-2M deals and get it to around 10. But that’s part of the problem. Not enough early stage money that’s ready and willing to invest much earlier than we’re comfortable with in Atlanta. Said is a great guy and was on our board at Vocalocity and I have much respect for him. However, I’m afraid they’ll fall into the same trap we’re already in. Local Supply and Demand Part of the local problem is 2 fold: not enough decent deals to invest larger dollars in and not enough smaller capital to invest in smaller deals. We need a $80M fund that will invest in 80-100 deals with enough follow-on capital. But here’s the dichotomy: even if we had it, we don’t have enough (currently) smaller local deals that are fundable. So, Atlanta would need to be willing to churn through some deals over a period of time to cultivate a culture change, a set of lifestyle changes and major ecosystem changes - and that’s going to be tough and painful. Here’s what I think are 5 key requirements to make this happen:
Here’s the danger Local money needs to understand a few things I’ve consistently heard:
Unfortunately, I don’t believe that the Atlanta startup community is at a cross roads — it’s not that simple. It’s more like a labyrinth. This problem is a multi-variable equation. And, it’s one whereby all parts have to work together pretty consistently. The local community has a lot of reservations all around. I do believe it can work. I do believe that a few leaders from each constituency can emerge and provide 80% of what’s needed to get us there. I also think it can happen. However, it will take some time. It will probably take 6-8 years for this to really work if we intend to see a major shift. That’s quite a long time in startup time - and here’s why: we need to get several rounds of failed startups (2-3 years) through the system and then get some decent base hits but a great set of teams. Then, we can go back through the normal cycle (4-5 years) to get some really decent hits. At that point, we’d have enough stuff in the pipeline that we could really change things. And, enough decent successes following the formula, that they’ll start their re-investment for the cycle to continue again and again. The other alternative is status quo, or worse, an imbalanced ecosystem. One example of imbalanced ecosystem is what’s happened in the last year in Atlanta. The entrepreneurs have taken the mantle of driving the startup ecosystem. That’s not entirely bad, but it’s also not sustainable. All the local events (that are meaningful) are being driven almost exclusively by entrepreneurs (myself included). The burden is heavy. Everyone needs to participate. Everyone needs to be involved. So, why move? Well, frankly, I’m both tired and scared. I’m tired of pushing hard and need to focus on my own startup right now. And I’m scared that if I don’t get every possible advantage in my own court, I’ll fail again. I really want Appcelerator to succeed in a big way. I believe I can change the world - at least the small part of the world that is impacted by what we’re doing. And, I believe that if we can even be partially successful in what we’re attempting to do, we will. I need every advantage I can get to make that happen. The Silicon Valley area is part of that plan because it puts me (and Appcelerator) in the heart of where things are happening today with a set of partners that have done it over and over again. The ecosystem is in place here and it’s working consistently. It’s not without its own set of new challenges: the valley is ruthless, expensive, somewhat overrated and definitely a different pace of life. But, with all that, it’s still the place to be. Very few significant technology companies make it big outside of the Silicon Valley - and that’s just the facts. One very prominent valley investor told me: “Jeff, if you want to be an actor you go to Hollywood. And, if you want to be a tech entrepreneur, you need to be in the valley.” So, I’m going to have to put my own self-interest (and that of Appcelerator) ahead of my altruistic concerns for Atlanta. At least for a while. If I’m successful, I do believe it will help Atlanta in many ways. So for now, I’m outta here. I’ll be living in Mountain View, California just off Castro Street and our new headquarters is in downtown Mountain View (just 3 blocks away from my house). I wish Atlanta the best of luck and I’ll really miss all my local friends and colleagues. You have been so good to me for so long and I really appreciate everyone’s well-wishes and congratulations. You’re in my heart and on my mind. I really hope we can keep in touch. One of my goals as part of this transition is to blog more - specifically about this experience and how it’s different (both good and bad). So, please stay tuned and subscribe to my blog (and my twitter stream if you want more rapid updates). |